Wine at The Galley Restaurant — Pairing Wine with Fish in Topsham

Wine is half the meal. We take it seriously.

Most fish restaurants don’t. The list is an afterthought — a few bottles chosen to hit price points, a house white that works with everything and distinguishes nothing. We’ve tried to do the opposite. The wine list at The Galley, in Topsham on the Exe Estuary, is built around the same principle as the food menu: find the thing that’s best for what’s on the plate, not the thing that’s easiest to source in bulk.

That means a list that changes — not weekly, like the food, but regularly — and a by-the-glass selection that’s good enough to drink through an entire meal without committing to a single bottle. It means being honest about what pairs well with delicate fish and what overwhelms it. And it means being willing to stock bottles that guests haven’t heard of alongside the ones they have.

“My one rule: match the weight of the wine to the weight of the dish. Sole with something mineral; turbot with a serious white Burgundy. Don’t put oaked Chardonnay against a piece of brill — it’ll bury the fish.” Patrick Mitchell · Manager & Co-owner, The Galley

How does wine pairing work with a menu that changes daily?

The challenge with The Galley’s food menu is that it changes with the Brixham catch — so the wine list has to be flexible rather than prescriptive. Rather than printing a fixed pairing for each dish, the front-of-house team are trained to talk about the wine in relation to what’s actually on the plate that evening. A turbot dish prepared with a rich beurre blanc needs a different wine from a John Dory grilled simply with herbs; recommending by the dish matters more than recommending by the grape.

The practical rule we follow: match the weight of the wine to the weight of the dish. Light, delicate fish — sole, sea bass, lemon sole — suit wines with good acidity and restraint. Richer preparations — bisques, butter sauces, shellfish — can carry more body and texture. The wine list is built around that principle rather than around grape varieties or regions.

What wines pair best with fish?

For white fish — sole, sea bass, brill

Delicate white fish is most easily overwhelmed by wine. High-acid whites with mineral character work best. On the current list, the wines we reach for first are the Muscadet Sur Lie ‘La Bretonnière’ from Maison Bretonnière in the Loire (zingy lime, creamy apple, super-fresh), the Picpoul de Pinet ‘Terra d’Eole Prestige’ from the Languedoc (floral nose, strong grapefruit and lemon), and the Mosel Riesling from Romerhof Weinkellerei in Piesport (medium-dry, honeyed, with a lime-fresh backbone). All three have the acidity to cut through the butter and cream that often accompany delicate fish without competing with the flavour of the fish itself. Heavier, oakier whites — certain New World Chardonnays, Viognier-led blends — can overpower a simple sole or brill preparation, and the kitchen tends to steer guests away from them when the dish is restrained.

For shellfish — crab, lobster, scallops

Shellfish carries more sweetness and body than most white fish, which means it can handle more textured wines. The Bourgogne Aligoté from Domaine Vincent Bouzereau is the every-day choice on the list — soft, citrus-led, wonderfully understated, and a natural fit with scallops or a crab starter. When the occasion warrants it, the Meursault ‘Les Narvaux’ from the same producer — rich, buttery, with hints of toasted hazelnut — is the bottle for lobster. For oysters, the choice is Champagne or English sparkling: the Pebblebed Brut NV from Ebford, just up the estuary, or the Baron de Beaupré Champagne Brut NV. Both have the acidity and effervescence to cut the brine cleanly.

For richer fish — turbot, John Dory, smoked fish

Turbot is the one fish that can genuinely support a serious white Burgundy. The Meursault ‘Les Narvaux’ from Domaine Vincent Bouzereau handles it; for guests who want premier-cru weight without the Meursault price, the St Aubin 1er Cru ‘La Chatenière’ from Domaine Gérard Thomas (next door to Chassagne — lime blossom, dried fruit, nutty peachy fruitiness) is the wine the front-of-house team most often recommend. John Dory, though lighter, takes a similar approach. Smoked fish works well with the Estate Dry Riesling from Louis Guntrum in Rheinhessen — spicy, dry, full of apricot and beeswax — which has enough texture to sit with the smoke and enough acidity to keep it honest.

Can you drink red wine with fish?

Yes, with some specificity. Light reds — Pinot Noir, Gamay, Poulsard — work with certain fish preparations, particularly those involving earthier flavours (mushrooms, lentils) or richer fish like salmon and tuna. The rule to avoid is tannic reds with delicate fish: the tannin reacts with the fish proteins and produces a metallic taste. The wine on the current list we point to for this is the Bourgogne Pinot Noir from Château de la Charrière, Domaine Yves Girardin — silky, fruit-forward, the kind of red Burgundy you can put alongside a piece of Brixham turbot without apology. A Cabernet Sauvignon, or the Barolo ‘San Carlo’ from Luigi Dezzani that sits at the top of the red list, would be a mistake against fish — they’re there for the Devon Ruby beef and the richer meat dishes.

The by-the-glass selection

The by-the-glass selection at The Galley changes regularly. The current list runs to ten whites, two rosés, five reds, four sparkling and three dessert wines available by the glass — enough range to drink through a full meal without committing to a single bottle. The team will always recommend a glass to go with whatever you’ve ordered.

A few of the bottles we’re recommending most often at the moment:

Covepoint Chardonnay — Lyme Bay Winery, Musbury, Devon. The wine the staff are most often pouring at the moment. Made by Lyme Bay from English grapes, it’s a moderately weighty white with bright citrus acidity, ripe melon and white stone fruit, and a subtle touch of oak. £7.50 / 125ml, £9.95 / 175ml, £39 / bottle.
Muscadet Sur Lie ‘La Bretonnière’ — Maison Bretonnière, Loire. The default by-the-glass for oysters, mussels and anything raw. £6.65 / 125ml, £8.50 / 175ml, £31.50 / bottle.
Estate Dry Riesling — Louis Guntrum, Rheinhessen. For smoked fish, scallops, and anything with a touch of richness or sweetness on the plate. £7.50 / 125ml, £9.95 / 175ml, £38 / bottle.
Bourgogne Pinot Noir — Château de la Charrière, Domaine Yves Girardin, Burgundy. The red we recommend with salmon, tuna and the richer fish dishes. Bottle only — £47.

Bottles and the wine list

The full list moves between £26 and £90 a bottle, mostly under £50. A handful of the bottles we’d point to as the character of the list:

Chablis — Domaine Albert Bichot, Burgundy. Classic Chablis — fresh and elegant on the nose, citrus nuances, tight, green minerality on the palate. The benchmark for white-fish pairing. £51.50.
St Aubin 1er Cru ‘La Chatenière’ — Domaine Gérard Thomas, Burgundy. Premier-cru weight at sub-£70 — the value-for-money bottle on the white Burgundy side of the list. £69.50.
Sancerre — Domaine Daulny, Loire. Exquisite, herbaceous, harmonious balanced acidity. The Sauvignon Blanc choice for anyone who finds Marlborough too overt. £46.50.
Côtes du Rhône (Organic & Biodynamic) — Domaine Roche-Audran, Rhône. Worked by hand, certified biodynamic, with the finesse of a mini-Châteauneuf. The natural-wine-curious bottle on the list. £36.50.
Sharpham Classic Cuvée — Sandridge Barton, Stoke Gabriel, Devon. Local sparkling done properly. Baked red apple, sultana, caramel, lemon rind, dry focused acidity and a delicate mousse. £11 / glass, £49.50 / bottle.

The full list is available in the restaurant and on request. For private dining events, the front-of-house team can suggest pairings for each course of a bespoke menu in advance — email [email protected] with the event details.

Wine for private dining

For private dining events in the upstairs room — fine dining for parties of twelve and up — the wine can be supplied by The Galley by the bottle, by the glass, or as pairings designed alongside the menu. Dan Kavanagh’s kitchen and the front-of-house team work on the pairing together — if a particular producer or style of wine matters to the guest, that conversation happens in advance rather than on the evening.

Frequently asked questions about wine at The Galley

Does The Galley have a good wine list?

The Galley's wine list is one of the things that distinguishes it from the other seafood restaurants in the Exeter and Devon area. The list is built around the food menu — specifically around fish and shellfish — and runs from a £26 house white up to a £90 Meursault, with most bottles under £50. The by-the-glass selection covers ten whites, two rosés, five reds, four sparkling and three dessert wines, so guests can drink a different wine with each course without committing to a bottle. The front-of-house team know the list well and will recommend by dish rather than by grape variety.

What is the house wine at The Galley?

The house white is The Galley Blanc from the Pays d'Oc in southern France — scented, balanced, with simple citrus notes and a refreshing finish. The house red is 'Red Herring' Shiraz from South Eastern Australia — deep red, soft tannins, a lingering fruit-driven finish. The house rosé is The Galley Rosé from Cépages du Sud in southern France — delicate pale pink with hints of ripe cherry, strawberry and zesty citrus, not unlike a Provence rosé. All three are £5.25 / 125ml, £6.50 / 175ml, £26 / bottle.

Does The Galley stock natural wine?

The list isn't a natural-wine list, but there's one specifically organic and biodynamic bottle on it: the Côtes du Rhône from Domaine Roche-Audran in the Rhône — soft and mellow, with the finesse of a small Châteauneuf. The list as a whole leans towards classic, small-grower producers rather than the natural-wine end of the spectrum: Domaine Vincent Bouzereau in Burgundy (the Aligoté and the Meursault 'Les Narvaux'), Domaine Daulny in Sancerre, Domaine Gérard Thomas in St Aubin, Maison Bretonnière in Muscadet. If a particular natural producer matters for a private dining occasion, the front-of-house team will source it where possible — email [email protected] with the details.

Book a table at The Galley to drink the list →